← Articles
How we actually decide on a score

How we actually decide on a score

June 16, 2026 · Lukas Berndt

People ask why we almost never give a game a perfect score, so here's the honest answer: we think a number should mean something, and if everything is a 4.8 then nothing is.

When one of us reviews a game, we play it the way a normal person would — in short sessions, over several days, on a real phone rather than a top-tier device. We note what delights us, what annoys us, and whether we keep wanting to come back.

The rating is mostly a gut feeling backed by those notes. Controls matter a lot to us, so does performance on cheaper hardware, and so does whether the core loop still feels good after the novelty wears off.

We also talk it out as a team. If someone wants to rate a game higher or lower, they have to defend it, and those arguments usually sharpen the final number. It's not science, but it's honest, and that's the best we can promise.

editorialratingsbehind the scenes